Page Contents
Introduction
Shake siding offers a timeless, rustic charm that enhances a home’s exterior. However, over time, exposure to weather elements can cause wear and tear, necessitating replacement. Whether you’re looking to restore your home’s aesthetic appeal, improve durability, or boost energy efficiency, shake siding replacement is an excellent investment. This guide provides a detailed overview of costs, materials, installation tips, and benefits of replacing shake siding.
Signs That Indicate Shake Siding Replacement Is Necessary
Before investing in new shake siding, it’s essential to determine whether a replacement is necessary. Some key signs include:
1. Warping and Cracking
Over time, siding is exposed to harsh weather conditions, including extreme heat, freezing temperatures, heavy rain, and strong winds. These elements can cause siding panels to bend, crack, or split. Warping occurs when siding absorbs moisture or is subjected to constant temperature fluctuations, making it expand and contract. Cracks and splits, on the other hand, can develop due to aging or physical impact (such as hail or flying debris). When siding loses its shape or structural integrity, it can no longer protect your home from the elements, leading to water infiltration and further damage. If you notice multiple areas with these issues, a replacement is necessary.
2. Mold and Mildew Growth
Siding should act as a protective barrier against moisture. However, if it starts trapping water due to cracks, improper installation, or deterioration, mold and mildew can thrive. These fungi not only create unsightly stains on your home’s exterior but can also cause health problems for occupants. Mold growth indicates that moisture is seeping into your home, potentially causing rot and weakening the siding and underlying materials. If left unchecked, this can lead to costly structural damage. If mold or mildew keeps reappearing despite thorough cleaning, it’s a sign that the siding is no longer effectively repelling moisture.
3. Frequent Repairs
If you find yourself constantly patching up sections of your siding due to cracks, warping, or leaks, it may be more practical to invest in a full replacement. While individual repairs can temporarily fix minor issues, they can add up in cost over time. Moreover, repeatedly repairing siding does not address underlying problems such as widespread material degradation or poor insulation. New siding installation provides long-term durability, improved energy efficiency, and a fresh look for your home, making it a more cost-effective solution.
4. Increased Energy Bills
Siding plays a crucial role in your home’s insulation. When it is compromised due to cracks, gaps, or deterioration, it allows heat to escape in the winter and enter in the summer. This forces your HVAC system to work harder to maintain a comfortable indoor temperature, resulting in higher energy bills. If you notice a consistent rise in your heating or cooling costs despite maintaining your HVAC system, your siding could be the culprit. Replacing old or damaged siding with insulated or energy-efficient materials can help regulate your home’s temperature, reducing energy consumption.
5. Fading and Discoloration
Over time, exposure to sunlight, harsh weather, and pollutants can cause siding to fade and lose its vibrant color. While some fading is natural, excessive discoloration is often a sign that the siding has aged beyond its lifespan. If cleaning and maintenance fail to restore its appearance, it means the material has deteriorated and may no longer provide adequate protection. New siding not only improves your home’s curb appeal but also ensures better durability and resistance to environmental factors.
Types of Shake Siding Materials for Replacement
When replacing shake siding, selecting the right material is crucial. Each material has unique advantages and drawbacks.
1. Wood Shake Siding
Wood shake siding is a classic and natural-looking exterior siding made from cedar, redwood, or other hardwoods. It gives homes a rustic, traditional appearance and is often used in cottage-style or historic homes.
✅ Pros:
- Natural Appearance – Offers a warm, authentic look that enhances curb appeal.
- Eco-Friendly – Made from natural materials and biodegradable. Some options are sustainably sourced.
- Customizable – Can be stained or painted in different colors to match your home’s aesthetic.
❌ Cons:
- High Maintenance – Requires regular staining, painting, or sealing to prevent rot and decay.
- Prone to Moisture Damage – Without proper maintenance, wood can warp, crack, or become infested with mold and insects.
- Costly – High-quality wood shakes are expensive, and installation can be labor-intensive.
💰 Cost: $$ – $$$ (Varies by wood type and quality)
🛠 Maintenance Level: High
2. Vinyl Shake Siding
Vinyl shake siding is a synthetic alternative that mimics the look of wood shakes while offering increased durability and lower maintenance requirements.
✅ Pros:
- Low Maintenance – No need for painting or staining. Simply wash occasionally to remove dirt and grime.
- Cost-Effective – More affordable than real wood or fiber cement siding.
- Variety of Colors & Textures – Available in numerous styles, including wood-look textures.
❌ Cons:
- Less Durable Than Other Options – Can become brittle in extreme cold and may crack upon impact.
- Fading Over Time – Prolonged exposure to sunlight can cause colors to fade, requiring repainting or replacement.
💰 Cost: $ – $$ (Budget-friendly)
🛠 Maintenance Level: Low
3. Fiber Cement Shake Siding
Made from a mix of cement, sand, and cellulose fibers, fiber cement shake siding is one of the most durable options available.
✅ Pros:
- Highly Durable – Resistant to fire, extreme weather, and insects.
- Moisture-Resistant – Unlike wood, it does not rot, swell, or warp when exposed to water.
- Minimal Upkeep – Requires very little maintenance beyond occasional cleaning and repainting.
❌ Cons:
- Heavy Material – Fiber cement is significantly heavier than vinyl or wood, requiring strong structural support.
- Professional Installation Needed – Due to its weight and specialized cutting requirements, professional installation is highly recommended.
- More Expensive – Higher material and installation costs compared to vinyl.
💰 Cost: $$ – $$$ (Mid-to-high range)
🛠 Maintenance Level: Low
4. Engineered Wood Shake Siding
Engineered wood shake siding is made from wood fibers, resin, and other bonding agents to create a more durable, moisture-resistant version of traditional wood siding.
✅ Pros:
- More Durable Than Natural Wood – Designed to resist rot, insects, and cracking better than real wood.
- Cost-Effective – Less expensive than fiber cement and some premium wood shakes.
- Eco-Friendly – Uses recycled wood materials, making it a sustainable option.
❌ Cons:
- Still Susceptible to Moisture – If not installed properly or maintained, engineered wood can absorb water and deteriorate over time.
- Requires Occasional Maintenance – Needs periodic repainting or sealing to maintain its look and longevity.
💰 Cost: $$ (Mid-range)
🛠 Maintenance Level: Moderate
Cost of Shake Siding Replacement
The cost of shake siding replacement depends on material choice, labor, and additional factors like insulation or trim work.
- Wood Shake Siding: $6 – $12 per square foot
- Vinyl Shake Siding: $4 – $7 per square foot
- Fiber Cement Shake Siding: $5 – $10 per square foot
- Engineered Wood Shake Siding: $4 – $9 per square foot
Additional costs may include:
- Removal of Old Siding: $1,000 – $3,000, depending on the size of the home.
- Labor Costs: $2 – $5 per square foot.
- Painting or Staining (if applicable): $1 – $3 per square foot.
Steps for Replacing Shake Siding
Replacing shake siding is a multi-step process that requires careful planning and execution.
1. Inspection and Removal
Before installing new siding, the old siding must be removed. Inspect the underlying structure for any damage or rot that needs repairs.
2. Surface Preparation
Ensure that the walls are clean and free of debris. If necessary, install a weather-resistant barrier or insulation to improve energy efficiency.
3. Measuring and Cutting
Measure the replacement shakes accurately. Use a saw to cut shakes to the required size while ensuring uniformity.
4. Installation of New Shake Siding
- Start at the bottom of the wall and work upwards.
- Overlap each shake properly to prevent moisture penetration.
- Secure each shake using nails or screws, depending on the material used.
5. Sealing and Finishing
- If using wood siding, apply a sealant or stain to protect it from moisture.
- Vinyl and fiber cement shakes typically come pre-finished, reducing the need for additional treatment.
Tips for a Successful Shake Siding Replacement
- Choose High-Quality Materials: Investing in high-quality siding ensures durability and reduces maintenance costs.
- Hire a Professional: While DIY installation is possible, hiring a professional ensures proper alignment and structural integrity.
- Consider Energy Efficiency: Adding insulation behind the siding can improve your home’s thermal efficiency.
- Follow Local Building Codes: Check with local authorities to ensure compliance with any zoning or construction regulations.
- Regular Maintenance: Even after replacement, routine maintenance will extend the lifespan of your siding.
Benefits of Shake Siding Replacement
- Enhanced Curb Appeal: New shake siding significantly improves your home’s aesthetic appeal.
- Increased Property Value: A well-maintained exterior boosts resale value.
- Improved Energy Efficiency: Properly installed siding reduces energy consumption by maintaining indoor temperatures.
- Better Weather Protection: High-quality shake siding resists harsh weather conditions, protecting your home’s structure.
- Reduced Maintenance Costs: Newer materials require less upkeep compared to aging, damaged siding.
Conclusion
Shake siding replacement is a valuable investment that enhances both the appearance and functionality of your home. By choosing the right material, budgeting appropriately, and following best practices for installation, you can enjoy long-lasting protection and aesthetic appeal. Whether opting for wood, vinyl, fiber cement, or engineered wood, proper planning ensures a successful and cost-effective replacement process.
